Media Spotlight – latest views and advice
Engine MHP’s media experts share their insights and guidance for navigating today’s complex landscape
Lose your head in an interview and it may be on the chopping block
Aggressive body language, raised voice and repeatedly interrupting the question were the hallmark signs of an interviewee losing control, as seen when Victoria Derbyshire challenged Ian Murray, Executive Director of the Society of Editors over its response to claims by the Duke and Duchess of Sussex.
The seasoned BBC News presenter caught an already irate Mr Murray in a contradiction and as his frustration boiled over he raised his hands in angry gesticulation, pointed his finger, shook his head and rolled his eyes.
Quite the exchange between Victoria Derbyshire and the head of the Society of Editors this morning pic.twitter.com/2DMxvqwZX1
— Tom Hourigan (@TomHourigan) March 9, 2021
Mr Murray’s argument was only harmed by this reaction and he instantly lost all credibility. Who would believe that the media are fair and balanced when defended by spokesperson who was enraged and unprofessional?
Lose your temper in a broadcast interview and it’s game over – it’s virtually impossible to backtrack and regain control. Delivery is more powerful, more compelling when it is calm and measured. In the face of challenging questions, your key messages are your safe place.
Follow the ABC method; acknowledge the question, bridge with a relevant segue and communicate your message. In a broadcast situation, this will enable you to move the interview in the direction you wish, it’s harder work for the interviewer to go backwards once you’ve moved on.
Mr Murray’s interview followed a widely criticised public statement by the Society, whose mission is to “fight for media freedom”, which refuted claims by Harry and Meghan that the UK media is bigoted. The day after Mr Murray’s interview the Society issued a ‘clarification’ following the backlash but by the end of the day Mr Murray had stepped down from his role.
Chaotic backdrop and hopeless messaging leaves minister exposed
The nation’s leading breakfast broadcasters took their turn to grill Health Minister Nadine Dorries, exposing her on two fronts; inadequate government messaging on the meagre 1% pay rise given to NHS staff and inability to handle difficult lines of questioning which showed her to be painfully out of touch.
Wrong message for the audience
Ms Dorries was given the impossible task of defending an indefensible decision yet this was made worse by her choice of words which displayed a vast chasm between policy makers and the people affected.
“I hope they receive the message we totally appreciate their efforts,” she said, “we hugely value them” but “unfortunately the 1% is all we can afford.” She went on to explain that we need to protect jobs and the economy. Cold comfort to nurses coming off a 12 hours night shift, watching the morning programmes. Absent was the human element; recognition of the disappointment and frustration that NHS staff would feel amidst the most difficult period of their professional lives.
“The government knew they couldn’t go without some pay offer but unfortunately the 1% is all we can afford”
— BBC Breakfast (@BBCBreakfast) March 5, 2021
Even her chaotic background, camera awkwardly positioned in a high corner exposing what must be the nation’s most peculiar loft, couldn’t distract from the cold heartedness of the messages.
Dodging difficult questions
Time after time she failed to answer direct questions which showed her to be ill prepared with suitable lines to take for obvious risk areas.
'If you were a nurse, how would you feel about the idea of a 1% payrise?' – Ben Shephard.@NadineDorries says she hopes nurses would understand that saving peoples jobs is a 'priority' for the govt.
She says 'without a strong economy, there will be no funding for the NHS.' pic.twitter.com/DSNAG3Bs1B
— Good Morning Britain (@GMB) March 5, 2021
Asking what a newly qualified nurse earns, LBC’s Nick Ferrari caught the Minister in a woeful example of bridging. Always remember; acknowledge, bridge, control. Ignoring the question won’t make it go away and will incense the journalist.
And don’t forget, when the cameras are on you must behave on radio as you would on television.
"Let's hope they spend that £6 a week wisely for saving the PM's life."
— LBC (@LBC) March 5, 2021
Learn from Dominic Raab, don’t get upstaged by a broom
Working from home is never easy, especially when you’ve got two children like Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab. So when he prepared to appear live on Sky News he was keen to make sure the interview wasn’t hijacked by his boys. Unfortunately it would appear his home office doesn’t have a lock, so Mr Raab barricaded himself inside by wedging a broom up against the door. That would have been fine, except the broom was in shot throughout his interview.
Mr Raab has since been mocked remorselessly on social media. Quite rightly.
“If we can just see a window of opportunity to reach those really vulnerable people… I think we will be doing a lot of good.”@DominicRaab calls for ceasefires to allow the #COVID19 vaccine rollout in the world's war zones.
— Sky News (@SkyNews) February 17, 2021
But at least it made a change to the union flags some of Mr Raab’s colleagues like Priti Patel, Grant Shapps and Gavin Williamson have on display.
Worse still is the broom cupboard sized office Matt Hancock performs his interviews from.
In this world of video interviewing backgrounds matter. They give the viewer an insight into the private lives of politicians, business leaders and celebrities.
Too many people over think it. They’ve clearly spent hours deciding which books should be put on display, which family portraits or ‘statement’ objects like football shirts.
— Richard Chambers (@richmchambers) January 13, 2021
The answer is to keep it simple.
A plain background, well-lit and with little clutter is ideal. Then the viewer – and social media – can concentrate on what you say and not where you are saying it.
Terminating an interview will always make it the story
A terse exchange between Piers Morgan and cabinet minister Therese Coffey that ended with a virtual ‘walk out’ is proof that making a scene only makes for negative news headlines.
Challenged on her choice of words during an interview on Good Morning Britain, Ms Coffey made excuses about a tight schedule and abruptly hung up the video call leaving the presenters to continue their criticism. The incident was soon trending on social media and was picked up by numerous media outlets.
The simple rule of broadcast is to always stay calm. To refute a statement use measured language like “I disagree, what’s important to remember is…” or “Those are not the words I would use, the real issue here is…” and then move the conversation along by returning to your key messages.
Remember, broadcast is as much about entertainment as it is about facts. If you take the bait from an interviewer who is seeking to sensationalise, you will only do yourself harm. Remain calm and the audience is more likely to sympathise with you – provided you continue to adequately answer the question. Calm avoidance of a question is just as frustrating for a viewer as irate refusal to answer.
⚡️ “DWP Secretary Therese Coffey 'walks out' on GMB interview”https://t.co/sy4PCspqg1
— Good Morning Britain (@GMB) January 25, 2021